For any adjustments or additions to this page, please email athletics@madeira.org
| Madeira Class of 2021 | |||
| Hannah Arndt | Swimming | New York University | Division III |
| Emma Faraon | Volleyball | Colorado College | Division III |
| Ruva Kiara | Basketball | Claremont McKenna College | Division III |
| Halle Johnson | Soccer | University of North Carolina Wilmington | Division I |
| Madeira Class of 2020 | |||
| Emma Bishop | Equestrian | College of Charleston | Division I |
| Amara Eley | Basketball | University of Rutgers – Camden | Division III |
| Grace Frerichs | Lacrosse | Tufts University | Division III |
| Annie Newton | Lacrosse | The United States Naval Academy | Division I |
| Lily Rathbun | Lacrosse | University of California, Berkeley | Division I |
| Molly Watts | Swim and Dive | Drexel University | Division I |
| Madeira Class of 2019 | Hamilton College | Division III | |
| Sophia Bernstein | Swim and Dive/Volleyball | Duquesne University | Division I |
| Meaghan Doyle | Swim and Dive | Denison University | Division III |
| Julie Kenyon | Track and Field | Massachusetts Institute of Technology | Division III |
| Trudy Painter | Lacrosse | St. Lawrence Univeersity | Division I |
| Lily Wildman | Ice Hockey | ||
| Madeira Class of 2018 | |||
| Jacey Albaugh | Equestrian | Texas Christian University | Division I |
| Izzy Gati | Swim and Dive | University of Kentucky | Division I |
| Maddie Heilbrun | Swim and Dive | Harvard University | Division I |
| Bella Godes | Lacrosse | Scripps College | Division III |
| Sarah Hughes | Lacrosse | Sewanee: The University of the South | Division III |
| Madeira Class of 2017 | |||
| Hannah Adams | Lacrosse | Massachusetts Institute of Technology | Division III |
| Emily Leins | Equestrian | University of Georgia | Division I |
| Alexa Zartman-Ball | Softball | Sarah Lawrence College | Division III |
| Madeira Class of 2016 | |||
| Sofia Abdirizak | Lacrosse | College of Wooster | Division III |
| Kylie Jordan | Swim and Dive | Duke University | Division I |
| Kita Konerth | Field Hockey | University of Connecticut | Division I |
| Mary McCarthy | Swim and Dive | Sewanee: The University of the South | Division I |
| Carter Ware | Equestrian | Sewanee: The University of the South | Division I |
| Jordan Williams | Tennis | Colgate University | Division I |
| Isabel Ruffin | Crew | Duke University | Division I |
| Claire Womack | Equestrian | Stanford University | Division I |
| Madeira Class of 2015 | |||
| Brianna Curran | Lacrosse | Hobart and William Smith Colleges | Division III |
| Sam Halo | Equestrian | Auburn University | Division I |
| Marina Pearce | Swim and Dive | St. Lawrence University | Division III |
| Brie Perkins | Lacrosse | Coastal Carolina University | Division I |
| Hanna Powers | Equestrian | University of South Carolina | Division I |
| Stephanie Royer | Swim and Dive | Rhodes College | Division III |
| Farrin Saba |
Swim and Dive - Track and Field/Cross Country |
Colgate University | Division I |
| Madeira Class of 2014 | |||
| Ingrid Boyum | Lacrosse | United States Naval Academy | Division I |
| Paige Humphrey | Volleyball | College of William and Mary | Division I |
| Carilynn Peyton | Equestrian | Southern Methodist University | Division I |
| Madison White | Lacrosse | Brown University | Division I |
| Madeira Class of 2013 | |||
| Madeline Alagia | Swim and Dive | Rhodes College | Division III |
| Kelsey Brown | Equestrian | Southern Methodist University | Division I |
| Natalie Konerth | Field Hockey | American University | Division I |
| Meredith Krieg | Soccer | Kenyon College | Division III |
| Victoria Turnbill | Equestrian | Mount Holyoke College | Division III |
| Devin Williams | Lacrosse | Massachusetts Institute of Technology | Division III |
| Madeira Class of 2012 | |||
| Breanna Atkinson | Volleyball | Duke University | Division I |
| Erica Glaser | Crew | Columbia University | Division I |
| Ann Griffin | Swim and Dive | Rhodes College | Division III |
| Delia Maresco | Soccer | Virginia Polytechnic Institute | Division I |
| Madeira Class of 2011 | |||
| Elise Ablin | Equestrian | Rollins College | Division II |
| Katie Decker | Field Hockey | University of Mary Washington | Division III |
| Anna Lewis | Field Hockey | Gettysburg College | Division III |
| Collin Reynolds | Equestrian | Southern Methodist University | Division I |
| Christia Ann Saunders | Swim and Dive | College of William and Mary | Division I |
| Madeira Class of 2010 | |||
| Carsen Anderson | Lacrosse | Dickinson College | Division III |
| Annie Laurie Hines | Crew | Colgate University | Division I |
| Audrey Hughes | Basketball | Lafayette College | Division I |
| Sally McHugh | Lacrosse | Occidental College | Division III |
| Madeira Class of 2009 | |||
| Alex Psaris | Swim and Dive | Bucknell University | Division I |
| Madeira Class of 2006 | |||
| Katherine McDonnell | Swim and Dive | The University of Virginia | Division I |
| Leigh Psaris | Swim and Dive | Emory University | Division III |
| Leslie Swinley | Swim and Dive | The University of Virginia | Division I |
| Madeira Class of 2005 | |||
| Jessica Williams | Swim and Dive | Brown University | Division I |
| Madeira Class of 2004 | |||
| Kelcey Moore | Swim and Dive | Georgetown University | Division I |
| Madeira Class of 2003 | |||
| Sarah Chuzi | Swim and Dive | Williams College | Division III |
| Madeira Class of 2002 | |||
| Lauren Edmondson | Swim and Dive | Williams College | Division III |
| Madeira Class of 2001 | |||
| Kristina Pawlowski | Swim and Dive | Lehigh University | Division I |
| Madeira Class of 1997 | |||
| Ariane Goldberg | Swim and Dive | Emory University | Division III |
| Nina Goldberg | Swim and Dive | Emory University | Division III |
| Beth Rogers | Swim and Dive | Columbia University | Division I |